Normally, this is told me because the aesthetic permit into author’s area

Have a tendency to whenever times are given, he could be offered having a day of one’s few days that really does not matches thereupon day since it inside the genuine record. One particular example happens in Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner out of Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney refers to sixteen October just like the Saturday, whether or not 16 October 1993 was a tuesday.

There are even contradictions when you look at the courses here. Such as for example, in the Harry Potter plus the Cup away from Flames, each other 1 September and 2 September are provided because the Mondays and you will, for the Harry Potter plus the Prisoner off Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is set with the 20 April, however, careful parsing of the text message demonstrates that it may keeps taken place zero after than simply February.

And, into the Harry Potter plus the Cup of Flame people say the Winners was chosen to your Monday 30 October, however, 30 October try a saturday from inside the 1994.

Inside the chapter 7 regarding Quidditch From Age, they do say the earliest Quidditch Business Mug happened in the 1473. Whether your tournament is actually kept every four years, it issues towards declaration when you look at the Cup from Fire that the 1994 Globe Glass try the newest 422nd. In the event the Quidditch From the Decades excellent, the brand new 422nd Quidditch Community Glass carry out actually fall-in the season 3161, in case Cup off Fire is good, the initial Industry Glass got stored inside the 306.

Historical difficulties [ ]

Although the collection, depending on the schedule produced from this new Chamber from Gifts reference, is determined regarding the 1990s, the fresh show often appears as though it’s set in the fresh new later nineties to mid-2000s, more or less concurrent to the guide of the courses. Within the Harry Potter additionally the Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to mention into the “predecessor” of Finest Minister of United kingdom. Depending on the significantly more than timeline, this should occur in the summertime of 1996, when the Primary Minister is actually John Big, whose immediate predecessor was a woman (is the reason basic ending up in Fudge, the publication mentions brand new election, however, Significant wasn’t very first selected and simply got over immediately after Thatcher retired.

You’ll be able to, not impractical, you to Fudge might be making reference to an even more distant ancestor, once the Thatcher took work environment just before Fudge purportedly turned Minister to possess Magic. (Whether or not you can think a scenario where Fudge was delegated by the Minister to own Wonders to generally meet into Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was at an inferior workplace.) Simultaneously, the fresh new character and you can reputation of the prime Minister portrayed appears to more closely matches that Tony Blair than simply out of John Significant. A post throughout the Every single day Mail notes you to Rowling was romantic to the up coming-Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brownish (will regarded as an opponent in order to Blair’s leaders of Work Party, who been successful him and you may turned into Finest Minister), hence she could have been attempting to tell you Blair’s poor side. In case the guides was invest connect with publication big date from Philosopher’s Stone, upcoming so it feel create take place in 2002 (once Blair became Best Minister).

However, it absolutely was later on stated that twenty-two November try a saturday, which it was a student in 1994

An equivalent state pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who had been mentioned as being 665 at the time of the newest earliest publication, however, Nicolas Flamel was a genuine historical contour and you can would not reach one many years up to 1996, inside the day the first guide is actually penned. The rebuttal because of it is the fact that the big date the newest “real” Nicolas Flamel was given birth to does not correspond with new Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.

Another problem can be obtained out-of Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure just like the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s meant throughout the series you to Hagrid got one updates within a couple of years regarding their expulsion of university in the 1942. In one scene away from Harry Potter plus the Cup off Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to convergence that have Molly’s age at school, it looks impractical one to she remembers a past gamekeeper. Although not, it’s possible you to Hagrid didn’t become a great gamekeeper immediately shortly after being expelled, but rather been while the Ogg’s secretary. This will be plausible due to the fact when Harry believes he commonly be expelled to possess flying into broomstick rather than consent in the first 12 months, he miracle in the event the he would be permitted to stick to as Hagrid’s secretary.

Vélemény, hozzászólás?

Az e-mail-címet nem tesszük közzé. A kötelező mezőket * karakterrel jelöltük